Welcome to Carter-MGM Insurance Agency!

We are an Independent New York Insurance Agency located in Poughkeepsie and serve the greater Hudson Valley area including Hyde Park, Highland, Lagrange, and Fishkill. Our agency was founded in 1963 and represents several of the insurance industry’s premier companies. Our agency provides NY and CT insurance coverage to fit the demands of any individual, family, or business. 

Learn More


What’s New?



Carter MGM Insurance provides unbiased and unparalleled service from quote through claims.Unlike other insurance agents, We have the freedom to competitively shop multiple insurance carriers and put together a plan that can save you money. You can thoroughly and confidently shop around in just one stop.  Read more news  Learn About Our Team  View Our Services


Follow Us



Cindy Sheils                 Owner, Cheesecake Heaven

I have done business with Carter Insurance for more than 25 years. They have always provided expert service and quick response to any problem. Jay always makes you feel like you have someone on your side. I would highly recommend Jay as he is creative and know how to make insurance work for you or your business in the best way possible.