PROTECTING WHAT MATTERS MOST
Securing your future



What We Offer
ABOUT CARTER-MGM INSURANCE
Carter-MGM Insurance Agency has been serving the Hudson Valley Community since 1963. We are a locally owned independent insurance agency offering our clients many insurance companies to choose from in order to best handle their needs. Our knowledgeable staff will assist you promptly and we look forward to providing you with the right kind of insurance advice.


COVERAGE OPTIONS
CLIENT SUPPORT
Our team provides dedicated support to help you choose the right coverage options for your needs. We are committed to ensuring that you have the protection you need for what matters most.
CLAIMS ASSISTANCE
In the event of a claim, we will guide you through the process and ensure a smooth and efficient resolution. Your peace of mind is our priority.
POLICY REVIEW
We offer regular policy reviews to ensure that your coverage always aligns with your current needs and circumstances. Our goal is to keep you well-protected.
CUSTOMIZED SOLUTIONS
We understand that every client is unique, which is why we tailor our solutions to fit your specific requirements. Your satisfaction is our measure of success.
THE CARTER-MGM INSURANCE DIFFERENCE
At Carter-MGM Insurance, we stand out by prioritizing our clients' peace of mind. Our commitment to personalized service and industry expertise ensures that you receive the attention and protection you deserve.
TAILOR-MADE APPROACH
Our approach is tailored to meet your individual needs, ensuring that you receive the right coverage for your unique circumstances.
CLIENT FOCUS
Putting our clients first is at the core of everything we do. We are dedicated to providing exceptional service and support at every step of your insurance journey.
PRECISE PROTECTION
We pay attention to the details to ensure that you have the precise protection you need. Our thorough approach guarantees that nothing is overlooked when it comes to your coverage.
TRUSTED RESULTS
Our track record of delivering trusted results speaks for itself. You can rely on us to provide the solutions and support that lead to lasting peace of mind.
CLIENT TESTIMONIALS
"Always friendly and always helpful. It's great to have a local agent you can quickly call and talk to if you have a question. Keep up the great work!"
Gary Killmer
"I have done business with Carter Insurance for more than 25 years. They have always provided expert service and quick response to any problem. Jay always makes you feel like you have someone on your side. I would highly recommend Jay as he is is creative and knows how to make insurance work for you or your business in the best way possible."
Cindy Shiels
Owner of Cheesecake Heaven
"Highly professional, caring agency. Taking great care of you and your most valuable assets, through careful client evaluation and meeting your individual Insurance needs. Carter MGM - a great choice for your families Insurance needs.
Donna Metzger
OUR TRUSTED CARRIERS




